*
On Gray Matter
Thomas Dai
*
L*STS: an Essay Daily Happening | About & Contents
Lists | Lasts | Losts | Lusts | Other
*
- While driving to work, I listen to a podcast about Pantone’s color of the year, “Cloud Dancer,” which the voices on the radio deride as a “nothing” sort of color, as apparently lifeless as the gray northwestern skies I am currently driving under.
- Googling the color later, I see that Cloud Dancer is really just a shade of white—not a bright “optical” white, nor a creamy off-white, but a cool-toned, “natural” white, a few nickels less silver than gray. I like gray. I like it a lot. If I had to begin an essay the way Maggie Nelson begins Bluets, by falling in love, piecemeal and then all at once, with a color, I would have to write about Pantone no. 13-4302: “Skywriting.” This is not an ashy charcoal gray or a shiny fish scale gray or a landlord-approved millennial gray. It is a gray akin to Cloud Dancer, more a tint than a color. Staring at it, one feels a bit bored, like the eye could flow in any direction.
- Writing can be like that, abstract in its pallor. Writing is gray to me, and it also comes from the sky. These gray skies over Pullman, over Chengdu, over Boston and other gray-cast cities I’ve lived in whilst writing.
- I remember the frigid gloam outside our kitchen window in Providence. I remember a time, too, when to be in a gray city was a symptom of having “made it” out of my green and gold Southern childhood, her sunburnt and adobe Southwest.
- What is the origin story to the brain magnet inscribed with the words “gray matter” on my fridge? All I know is my ex bought it for me, because she understood my aesthetic.
- According to recent data-gathering efforts, I own twelve gray sweaters and sweatshirts, three gray blazers, one gray overcoat, and four pairs of gray slacks. The Internet will tell you that gray clothes show sweat stains easily, but I have not been to a gym since 2013. Showing sweat easily is not something I consider when dressing to meet my days.
- These days, I like gray because it makes all the colors around it more vibrant in contrast, or perhaps because I am a city person still playacting at urbanity while residing in a landscape of brown and yellow hills. (I do not believe in the evolutionary gospel of adapting to one’s surroundings.)
- Gray is concrete to me: the softest hard thing I know. The architecture of concrete is known as brutalism. In Brutalism, materials are left unadorned, nothing more or less than what they are. Form without ornament. Design undistracted by color.
- My ex and I went to Montreal in 2018. It was time I thought to go and see a pyramid of concrete cubes set down by the frozen St. Lawrence, also known as Moshe Safdie's Habitat 67, an icon of brutalist design. The cubes are not just for show; they’re inhabited, though we wondered how the plumbing worked inside such a jumble of boxes.
- I prefer the less dizzying grays of Tadao Ando, an architect known for his direct and dogmatic approach to construction. A building outside Osaka called The Church of Light is possibly his most famous structure. The last time I was in Japan, I could not visit the Church of Light. Demand had exceeded supply; these grays were reserved for the congregants.
- For Ando, a building is just a container, a threshold we cross and recross until the circulatory system stops, until it all fades to gray. His best designs give a home to that fading.
- I have been accused, mostly by myself, of seeing and writing and thinking and feeling in too many shades of gray. Perhaps the grays of Ando and Safdie call with an alto blandness to people like me who reside in the straits between certainty and doubt, clarity and occlusion. Perhaps these people would do well to decorate with more color.
- The Arctic grayling is a fish. I do not know why I know this. Earl Grey is the tea I drink, named for a British man who helped abolish slavery across her majesty’s empire.
- I’m shocked to hear that my old favorite show, Grey’s Anatomy, is on its twenty-third season. For ten of those seasons, until Sandra Oh’s character left Seattle for even greyer pastures (Zurich), I thought I’d wake up one day a doctor.
- I’m skating around the more personal and piercing grays—grays like my ex’s eyes, which were greenish in the light, but gray before coffee. Gray was the day I walked down to the beachhead and gave it all away. Gray were the birds—petrels, I want to say—that watched as I unraveled what up to that point had been our life. These grays, too, were brutalist.
- Afterwards, there was no question about who would keep the cat. She is gray, and so she is mine. We had named her Ando; we had taught her how to sit; we had adored, for a time, the concrete softness of our life together.
- The couches we picked up off the street, the first building we lived in, the car we used to split, the smoke that passed between us for years until it didn’t. All so gray. When my ex decided to spray paint some of our furniture turquoise, I should’ve known it was over.
- To capitulate to someone else’s aesthetic is one way to show love. I have to believe there are so many others.
*
This little piece emerged from a prompt I always assign in undergrad nonfiction classes: "pick a color, one with intense personal significance for you, and let it dictate the terms of your essay." I always enjoy this week because the students and I get to nerd out about color theory, synaesthesia, Pantone's silly color codes, and the chromatic spectrum of feeling blue, bleeding red, yearning for green, etc. My students would probably identify gray as a millennial color, and I righteously agree. Recently, I learned that I was born one year after the narrow band of time (1990-1991) in which the greatest number of millennial babies were ushered into the world. Having just missed the boat on being "peak millennial," I like to think my gray-fixation is related to my lifelong (and rather millennial) desire to "get in" with the right crowd, to wear the right clothes, and sing the right political tune. But liking a color in earnest is more personal, an individualist's sport. Gray diverts my mind to so many things, including things (heartbreak, lost love, lost time) that transcend, or cut down to size, issues of taste and aesthetic. Whether the grays I'm elegizing here are "true" colors is debatable, but these grays have suffused me: I can't unsee their paleness or unfeel their chill. This snapshot-style essay is my attestation to that effect.
Thomas Dai is the author of Take My Name but Say It Slow: Essays, which won the 2026 Lambda Literary Award for best Gay Memoir/Biography. He currently serves as the critic-at-large for The Georgia Review, and his writing has appeared or is forthcoming in The American Scholar, Electric Literature, New England Review, The Yale Review, and elsewhere. He lives in a city named Moscow and teaches creative writing at the University of Idaho.



